Best Toasters

Best Toasters 2018

Everyone knows that breakfast is the most important meal of the day. With that thought in mind, it’s important to have a good quality meal in the morning to make sure you get a good start to your day.

For many Americans, toast is one of the most standard and popular choices for a breakfast food, so you need to make sure you also have a good quality toaster to make sure that your toast is browned just right.

Toasters come in many types and sizes from an appliance that is very basic to a large market of toasters that get fairly complicated.

When the time comes to replace your trusted toaster, you will find a wide range of toasters on the market to choose from that include digital settings to toasters that can bake. Here are a few tips on what to look for in the best toaster and a few reviews to help you start shopping.

Types of Toasters

Pop-Up Toasters

Also known as basic toasters, pop-up toasters are the picture you would find of a toaster in a dictionary. Available in either two or four slots, it has the basic function of dropping in your toast, pressing the lever down to toast the bread, and then it pops up when it is done.

These toasters have the specific design to toast and often work better when you use toast in standard sizes although some come with wider slots that let you toast bagels and other pastries.

Pop-up toasters are easy to use, inexpensive, and are easy to find but keep in mind that you can’t use it for any other type of cooking and you can only make a couple slices of toast at a time.

Countertop Toaster Oven

Also known as a good way to make toast, countertop toaster ovens can also be used for other types of cooking. Purchased by those that way another way or a replacement for a regular oven, countertop toaster ovens use less electricity and require less time to cook with.

Depending on the size of countertop toaster oven you choose, they range from compact requiring a small footprint to larger models that can make up to nine slices of toast at one time which can help make mornings easier for larger families.

Countertop toaster ovens are more expensive than a pop-up toaster but they make up for the cost of the extra features they provide. Making pizza, baking cookies, and even roasting rotisserie chickens are just a few of the extra elements.

For some people, these extra features are too much but for some, it’s a smart buy if you want something that will do many of the tasks you would otherwise use a regular oven for.

Top Three Considerations When Buying a Toaster


When considering the toaster size that you want, you need to know how many slice of toast you want to toast at once, how large do you want the slots to be, and how much counter space do you have available.

After you decide how many slices you want to toast, your shopping will become a lot easier as you will find the toasting capacity of most toasters in their name.

The size of the slots only pertains to pop-up toasters, but it is an important consideration if you plan to toast something larger than the regular piece of bread.

You can find toasters with large slots that can toast English muffins, bagels, and even Texas toast.

The amount of space you have on your countertop is an important consideration, especially if you have limited countertop space. If you need something compact and pretty small, a pop-up toaster will be the best choice as it won’t take up too much counter space.

On the other hand, countertop ovens have a variety of sizes to choose from and a larger size can be handy when making things like pizza so it is worth giving a lot of counter space. It’s important to decide on the balance between what you want your toaster to do and the amount of space you want to dedicate to it.


Pop-up toasters are the most inexpensive option when it comes to toasters but even they can cost over $100 depending on the model and brand you choose. Countertop toaster ovens will be even more and can come in around $300 for some models and brands. In either case, you will find a surprisingly large price range for each of the models.

The reason for this wide range is due to a couple of factors. You can find very simple pop-up toaster models that do the basic job of toasting just fine, but they are often made of cheap materials that probably won’t last you very long. Models that fall on the other side of the price range will come with lots of settings and features that you may not end up even using. Most consumers want something in the middle that can toast well and that is durable enough to last a while.

When considering the price of countertop ovens, there are even more features available that can drive up the price. Plus, having a more compact or simpler countertop toaster oven can actually cost you more.


Deciding on how you will be using your toaster is probably one of the biggest considerations on this list. If you have simple needs that only require the toaster to toast standard sized slices of bread, then pretty much any toaster will work, although you will still want to avoid cheaply made toasters that may not last long.

If you plan to toast other types of things like waffles, pastries, English muffins, and bagels, then you will need to make sure you have a model that has large enough slots and the correct settings to toast these items right. Only purchase a counter toaster if you plan to use it like a mini oven since you will only be giving up counter space and paying extra money for features you won’t be using.

Other Considerations


Simple toasters will come with the basic settings that will allow you to toast at dark, medium, or light levels. Most people are content with that while others want more setting options. It’s not uncommon for a pop-up toaster to also have a bagel option that will brown one side more than the other side. A defrost button can also be handy if you often put frozen waffles or toast in the toaster, and if everyone in your family has a different darkness setting preference, it’s a good idea to get a toaster with a range of browning settings.

Some toasters will also come with presets that can make your cooking process faster and simpler while having a convection option will allow you to cook food faster and more evenly. A rotisserie option lets you cook chickens and turkeys that are full of flavor and texture. There are lots of options to think about, so make sure to decide which settings are the most important to you before starting to shop.

Ease of Use and Cleaning

Once you have figured out your setting preferences, most toasters are pretty easy to use. Along with having the right sized toaster, making sure your toaster has the correct settings is the key to how easy it will be to use. Your toaster should be able to make as much toast as you need all at once so you aren’t stuck next to the toaster all morning.
Cleaning your toaster can be a little more complicated and have a slide-out crumb tray can make it easier. Plus, toasters with nonstick interiors can be easier to clean out than those without them


You want your toaster to last you a few years, and it’s not uncommon for consumers to use the same toaster for a decade or more. Read reviews and get to know the reputation of the manufacturer to know if your toaster is going to be durable enough to last you a few years. Some pop-up toasters and countertop ovens come with a warranty and usually a more expensive model with tend to last longer, but that isn’t always the case.

Features to Look for in a Toaster

Self-Adjusting Guides — With a self-adjusting guide, you can guarantee that your toast is centered well so it will toast evenly.

Cancel Button — A cancel button lets you stop toasting when you are concerned that the toast is burning.

Crumb Tray — With a crumb tray, you can easily collect the crumbs making cleaning your toaster quick and efficient.

Convection Heating — With convection heating, a toaster oven can cook food faster and more evenly.

Best Toaster Reviews

Oster 2-Slice Toaster

If you are looking for an attractive addition to your kitchen appliances, the Oster 2-slice Toaster provides you with a personalized and consistent toasting experience. With extra wide slots, you can fit bagels, thick slices of bread, and artisan bread into this toaster. Plus, you have seven shade options to choose from allowing you to make your toast exactly the way you like it.

There is also an easy to clean removable crumb tray and dual bread guides that will automatically adjust for your convenience. The included toast lift will lift your toast right to the top allowing you easy access and ensures there are no burned fingers. The Oster 2-slice Toaster also includes an anti-jam feature that will automatically turn off the toaster as an added safety measure.

Users were happy with the look, color, and design of the toaster. The dials are simple and easy to use and even though it is a lightweight toaster and plastic, it doesn’t feel cheap. It matches slate appliances well and is a great option for those that really want the basic setting options.

Farberware Digital 4 Slice Stainless Steel Toaster

If you are searching for the perfect toaster, you need to check out the Farberware Digital 4-Slice Toaster. With 1500 watts, this stainless steel toaster has durable housing that will last you a long time. It also features an elegant design and digital technology that will be a great addition to your home and gives you a powerful performance.

The Farberware Digital Toaster includes multiple toasting options and a digital interface. With the Digital Shade Control setting, you get a wide range of browning options that allow you to customize any type of bread. You also get dedicated buttons that allow you to defrost, cancel, reheat, or toast bagels.

This versatile toaster allows you to toast a wide variety of bread and also features a large slot that guarantees you can toast your favorite type of bread without hassles. The removable crumb tray makes clean up easy and the cord wrap found underneath the toaster helps you to hide unsightly power cords when you aren’t using them.

Users found that the display was easy to read and to adjust, and they loved the dual controls so they could make two pieces of bread with different settings at the same time. They also liked that it had a bagel toasting option and that they could toast a large piece of bread like Texas toast.

Proctor Silex Toaster


If you are looking for toast that is consistently delicious, the Proctor Silex Toaster features a two slice capacity, auto shutoff, and it allows you to select the setting to make toast that suits your preferences. You can toast any bread type by just pushing a button, and the toast boost feature allows you to remove hot toast by raising it higher giving you a better grasp, especially on smaller pieces.

The crumb tray slides out conveniently for easy cleanup of crumbs. The shade selector gives you perfect results with bagels, waffles, and toast and the auto shutoff guarantees that toasting will stop when it is supposed to so you don’t have to monitor it.

Users loved the size of the toaster and how simple it was to make a great piece of toast. It’s not a fancy machine but it takes up very little counter space, is lightweight, and easy to clean.

Hamilton Beach 4 slices Cool Touch Toaster

Toast everything perfectly brown every time with the Hamilton Beach 4-Slice Cool Touch Toaster. You can make bagels that are crunchy on the outside but soft inside or frozen waffles that are cooked all the way through. Featuring several toasting functions, this toaster also has a browning dial that allows you to set your tastes.

The Cool Touch Toaster has wide slots measuring 1.5 inches that can fit artisan bread and thick bagels. Each side of the toaster works independently of the other so you can make darker toast in one side while giving a light toast on the other. The Automatic Toast Boost is also available to make sure the contents are high enough to be removed easily whether it’s an English muffin or a bagel.

Another great feature is the Frozen Toast and Frozen Bagel feature that allows you to thaw and heat through frozen toast and bagels. Available in classic black with a sleek but simple design that features a cool-touch exterior will fit in well with your kitchen décor. Plus, it features a crumb tray that easily slides out from the bottom to make clean up quick and simple.

Users loved that you got a lot of features for the money. People with kids liked that it was cool to the touch and as separate settings for each slot which makes it easier to get everyone’s order done quickly in the morning. Others loved that it can toast frozen foods and that it has a bagel setting.

Stainless Steel 2-slice toaster

A great addition to your kitchen, the TOBOX Stainless Steel 2-slice toaster will look great on your counter with its stunning brushed stainless steel body. Equipped with wide slots for waffles, toast, and toaster pastries, the TOBOX includes shade control settings that give you a wide range of browning options allowing you to customize any type of bread.
With multiple toasting functions, the TOBOX is easy to operate and has an easy to clean slide out crumb tray. It also includes quick buttons including reheating, defrosting, and canceling.

Users loved what you get for the price. They felt that is was a nice and clean looking toaster with a great design. They also liked the crumb tray which made cleaning it easier and it’s defrost option was very handy.

Oster 2-Slice Toaster

Nothing is better than starting your day with toast made just the way you like it. The Oster 2-slice toaster is equipped to toast bagels and any type of bread. With advanced toasting technology, this toaster includes settings from light to dark that give you consistent results each time you use it. The included toast lift also makes it easy to access your toast when it’s done.

You will always get the perfect shade and texture bagel, muffin, bagel, or toast. With its metallic finish and sleek design, the Oster 2-slice Toaster looks good with any kitchen décor. This easy to use toaster also features an easy to clean removable crumb tray.
Users found that it was very shiny, so make sure that is what you are looking for before purchasing this toaster. It also does a great job of toasting bread, even larger pieces although you did need to play with the settings some to get the toasting just right.

Hamilton Beach Toastation

Style and functionality come together with the Hamilton Beach Toastation. This is a 2-in-1 Toaster and Oven that browns toast and cooks meals. As a 2-slice toaster, you can fit bagels, thick bread, and bakes goods into the 1 ½ inch wide slots. The oven portion on the bottom can fit up to two 16 inch slices of pizza, and it allows you to easily cook snack and meals.

With a removable crumb tray, this is an easy to maintain and clean toaster that also includes an auto shutoff element that saves on power and is an added safety and convenience feature. You get consistent performance with either the 2-slice toaster or the oven temperature controls. The Hamilton Beach Toastation has a sleek and compact design that is perfect for campers, dorm rooms, and other places that you need versatility and simplicity when you are cooking.

Users found that the toaster toasts evenly has a great retro design. This is a good product for cooking bagels, frozen waffles, toast, and even hot dog buns. The oven part is good for cooking foods that are flat like pizza slices, chicken nuggets, and French fries. Overall, consumers found it very useful and great for couples.

Hamilton Beach Stainless Steel Toaster

If you are looking for an attractive and functional toaster, the Hamilton Beach Stainless Steel Toaster has a ton of features and four extra wide slots. Featuring the high-lift toast boost, you can easily grab your toast with the high lift that makes removal easier. It is also perfect for English muffins, bagels, and artisan bread with its extra wide slots.

With the shade selector, you can choose your preferred browning level, and the automatic shutoff makes sure that it turns off by the end of the toasting cycle, even if the toaster gets jammed with food. Constructed with a finish of brushed stainless steel, this Hamilton Beach toaster will work well with any kitchen décor. Plus, it has a handy crumb tray that slides out for easy cleanup and features a cord wrap for convenient storage.

Users thought that the toaster was rugged and nice looking. They loved the lift design that lets you reach smaller slices and keeps you from having to dig the toast out, and they also liked the slide-out crumb tray that lets you clean out loose particles easily. Even though it is pretty lightweight, it’s not a cheap toaster that toasts lots of items well like English muffins and bagels without having to worry about them getting stuck.

Hamilton Beach Cool-Wall Toaster

With a practical and sleek design, the Hamilton Beach Cool-Wall Toaster is a perfect addition to any contemporary kitchen. This is a popular design that also features an expert toasting experience. With wide slots and smart button, you can warm bagels and uniformly toast them while the advanced toasting technology guarantees consistent results every time you use it.

Equipped with automatic shutoff and toast boost, the Hamilton Beach allows you to easily retrieve your toast with an extra boost and the automatic shutoff guarantees your toast won’t overcook. This is a reliable and compact toaster that also features a defrost setting that can defrost and toast in just one step and a bagel setting that warms the round side while toasting the cut side. This durable toaster will last you a few years and includes features like SureGuard heating elements that are shock-resistant and give you that added safety feature.

Users really like the value and all the features that you get for such an affordable toaster, and it comes with a long warranty. The toasting function works really well and you don’t have to worry about it over-toasting the bread. Plus, it works surprisingly fast and is really easy to clean out.

Black & Decker 4-Slice Toaster

With sleek styling and versatile capabilities, the Black & Decker 4-Slice Toaster can easily toast bagels, frozen waffles, homemade bread, toaster pastries, and hash browns. Featuring bagel, cancel, and frozen functions, this toaster is a great addition to your kitchen with its 1400 watts and extra wide slots that self-adjust. You also get dual control panels that operate two of the slots independently from the other two.

The Black &Decker also features a function indicator so you can easily use the different function along with the variable toast shade selectors. The bagel function keeps the inside crispy and the outside warm. It also features removable trays for quick cleanup along with the cord-wrap storage and cool-touch housing.

Users enjoyed the modern look of the toaster and that it toasts bread very evenly. They also enjoyed that it toasts bagels well and how consistent it is every time you use it. They also liked all the options for browning levels and that it had a cancel button so you can stop the toasting process if necessary.

Leave a Comment